Books

Show only the books you use. The best price (gold) then comes from these. Saved in this browser.

Toronto Blue Jays at New York Yankees odds

Toronto
Blue Jays
SM rating 1515 · #12
4 – 5
Final
Yankees -1.5 did not cover
Over 8.5
vs the most common closing line
Tuesday, May 19
7:05 PM ET
Yankee Stadium
New York
Yankees
SM rating 1556 · #3
TOR 42%NYY 58%
Fair moneyline
+138 / -138
TOR / NYY, no vig
Market win %
45% / 55%
No-vig average of the books
Model vs market
NYY +3 pts
SharpModels 58% · market 55% (no vig)
Ratings
1515 / 1556
TOR / NYY, SharpModels

SharpModels is a benchmark built only from team ratings: it doesn't see injuries, rest or lineup news. When it and the market disagree, the market often knows something.

Closing lines

This game was played before we started collecting prices (22 October 2026), so we have its closing prices only, from DraftKings, BetMGM and bet365: no line movement or player props. A price can differ from the book's own by a cent or two.

MarketBest
Blue Jays
Moneyline
+115
BetMGM
+109 +115 +110
Yankees
Moneyline
-130
bet365
-133 -139 -130
Blue Jays
Spread
+1.5-179
BetMGM
+1-141 +1.5-179 +1.5-185
Yankees
Spread
-1.5+155
bet365
-1+107 -1.5+145 -1.5+155
Over
Total
8.5-120
bet365
8.5-122 8.5-120 8.5-120
Under
Total
8.5+100
bet365
8.5+100 8.5+100 8.5+100
Margin
Moneyline
2.9% 4.7%4.5%4.0%

Margin: how much a book builds into its moneyline (its implied chances add up to more than 100%). Lower is fairer; the lowest is in green. Under Best, the margin if you took the best price on each side.

Every price change, book by book: tap the table icon by any selection, line, team total or player.

Best spread and total weigh the line against the price: a better line is worth paying a little more for, most of all onto key numbers (half a point is worth more where games often land). Moneyline: simply the best price.

Alternate lines

NYY line
-5
TOR +5
+540-1000 - -
-4.5
TOR +4.5
+417-714 - -
-4
TOR +4
+395-667 - -
-3.5
TOR +3.5
+307-455 +320-476 -
-3
TOR +3
+283-417 - -
-2.5
TOR +2.5
+218-303 +210-294 -
-2
TOR +2
+192-263 - -
-1.5
TOR +1.5
+152-185 +145-179 +155-185
-1
TOR +1
+107-141 - -
+1
TOR -1
-182+137 - -
+1.5
TOR -1.5
-217+163 -238+175 -
+2
TOR -2
-294+214 - -
+2.5
TOR -2.5
-345+241 -385+270 -
+3
TOR -3
-476+319 - -
+3.5
TOR -3.5
-526+346 -625+400 -
+4
TOR -4
-769+452 - -
+4.5
TOR -4.5
-833+476 - -

Top number: NYY at that line; bottom: TOR at the opposite line. Gold = best top number.

Total
3
Over / Under
- -10000+1550 -
3.5
Over / Under
- -2000+800 -
4
Over / Under
- -2000+775 -
4.5
Over / Under
- -1000+550 -
5
Over / Under
- -909+500 -
5.5
Over / Under
-455+299 -476+320 -
6
Over / Under
-400+274 -417+290 -
6.5
Over / Under
-294+211 -303+220 -
7
Over / Under
-244+181 -250+185 -
7.5
Over / Under
-175+133 -179+135 -
8
Over / Under
-152+116 -154+118 -
8.5
Over / Under
-122+100 -120+100 -120+100
9
Over / Under
-101-130 +105-139 -
9.5
Over / Under
+120-159 +130-169 -
10
Over / Under
+142-189 +155-208 -
10.5
Over / Under
+157-208 +175-238 -
11
Over / Under
+202-278 +240-333 -
11.5
Over / Under
+226-312 +250-357 -
12
Over / Under
+277-400 +310-455 -
12.5
Over / Under
+296-435 +333-500 -
13
Over / Under
+388-625 +450-769 -
13.5
Over / Under
+413-714 +475-833 -
14
Over / Under
- +575-1111 -

Top number: over; bottom: under. Gold = best top number.